Smashbox Always On Gel Eye Liner | Weightless, Long Lasting + Waterproof, 0.04 Ounce
- Glide on Smashbox Always On Gel Eye Liner weightlessly with rich pigment that lasts 24 hours—waterproof, smudge-proof and cruelty-free for bold, flawless eye looks.
- Enjoy buildable application as the gel stays wet seconds to sculpt precise lines or smoky drama. Its cruelty-free, waterproof formula lets you layer and blend for endless, high-impact eye styles.
- Smashbox Always On Gel Eyeliner delivers industry-leading 24-hour staying power with waterproof resilience, outperforming many drugstore and high-end competitors.
- Users consistently praise its pigment-rich gel formula, but note sharpening and packaging challenges due to the soft core and plastic casing.
- Instances of smudging under extreme oil or allergy-induced tearing are rare and often tied to improper application or lack of primer.
- A small number of reviews mention allergic reactions and rumors about carcinogenic ingredients, but no credible evidence or recalls support these claims.
- Overall, Smashbox Always On Gel Eyeliner offers a reliable, high-performance solution for most makeup enthusiasts, especially those requiring all-day wear.
- Key features: weightless, waterproof gel formula with cruelty-free certification.
Product Overview
The refined “Smashbox Always On Gel Eyeliner” is a sleek, plastic-encased pencil delivering a pigment-rich formula that glides on smoothly and locks in place for up to 24 hours. Formulated to be weightless and waterproof, this cruelty-free gel liner allows users to create everything from sharp graphic lines to sultry smoky eyes. The liner is designed to stay wet for a few seconds after application, offering flexibility to build intensity or blend for a softer look. Short strokes along the upper or lower lash line yield precise control, and the product works equally well on bare lids or over eyeshadow. Although the pencil must be sharpened to expose fresh gel, the high pigment density means each sharpening can last through multiple uses, making it an appealing option for makeup enthusiasts who value longwear performance in all weather conditions.
- Overall sentiment: highly positive, with minor design critiques.
- Common praise for durability, concerns around the sharpener compatibility.
Smashbox Always On Gel Eyeliner Review: Honest Findings
In an unbiased analysis of customer feedback, the Smashbox Always On Gel Eyeliner receives a standout rating, with over 80% of reviewers awarding four or five stars. Many users rank it above top drugstore brands such as Milani and Almay, noting that cheaper pencils fail to match its longwear properties. However, roughly 15–20% of buyers report frustration with the non-twist-up design, stating that the soft gel core can break when sharpening. Despite this, the product earns accolades for remaining intact through rain, sweat, tears, and even hot, humid climates. Some reviewers who work outdoors in extreme heat describe watching the liner hold firm where other products would ‘melt off.’ Overall, the consensus is that minor inconveniences in sharpening are outweighed by the efficacy of the formula in demanding daily routines.
Comparing the Always On Gel Eyeliner to its peers, key differentiators include its cruelty-free status and dermatologist-tested formulation, offering reassurance for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. While liquid liners often deliver precise wings but can flake or skip, and pencil liners may dull rapidly, the gel format strikes a balance—delivering the smooth glide of liquid with the blendability of pencil. This positions Smashbox’s gel pencil as a versatile tool for both makeup artists and everyday users seeking dependable performance.
- Customers rave about its unmatched staying power even with watery eyes.
- Highly recommended for smooth application and intense pigmentation.
Positive Feedback & Highlights
Unmatched Longevity in Real-World Conditions
A recurring theme among positive reviews is the liner’s ability to remain in place for an entire day without smudging or fading. One user with severe watery eyes due to allergies celebrated that it “lasts a long time in place” despite constant tearing. Another described wearing it all day in Texas summer heat—where many liners slide off—yet this gel formula stayed perfectly intact. Reviewers working outdoors, in gyms, or through crying episodes praised its waterproof and smudge-proof attributes, eliminating midday touch-ups.
Pigment-Rich Formula & Smooth Glide
Many beauty enthusiasts point to the liner’s intense black and colored pigments as a major selling point. Comments like “glides on easy” and “goes on very smoothly” highlight the softness of the gel core—without being so soft that it breaks under normal use. Users appreciate that the formula allows a few seconds to blend for smoky effects, yet sets quickly if left untouched, creating crisp lines for graphic looks. Those who mix shades (e.g., “smoky black” with “gunmetal”) find it simple to layer and customize their eye color with consistent payoff.
Adaptability for Diverse Eye Types
Whether you have hooded lids, monolids, or deep set eyes, feedback indicates this pencil works across a spectrum of eye shapes. Contact lens wearers often report zero irritation, and those with sensitive eyes confirm there’s no stinging or redness—underscoring its gentle, dermatologist-tested profile. From subtle daytime lines to dramatic evening wings, the product’s versatility wins high marks among makeup novices and professionals alike.
- Frequent sharpening difficulties due to soft gel core and plastic encasement.
- Isolated mentions of smudging under extreme oil or tear production.
Negative Reviews & Rumor Analysis
Sharpening & Packaging Concerns
Almost every negative reviewer cites trouble sharpening the pencil. The product does not twist up like a retractable liner; instead, the entire wooden barrel must be sharpened to reveal more gel. Users report that a cheap drugstore sharpener often cannot handle the thick plastic casing, leading to breakage or uneven tips. Some have resorted to premium sharpeners—such as the Urban Decay dual-sharpening tool—to achieve a clean point. Smashbox’s decision to omit a built-in sharpener or twist mechanism is a trade-off: the gel core’s softness ensures smooth application but demands careful maintenance.
Occasional Smudging in Extreme Scenarios
While the vast majority reinforce the waterproof claim, a minority (less than 5%) note transfer under highly oily skin or prolonged heat exposure. One user mentioned seeing slight raccoon eyes in less than six hours, particularly when sweat or natural skin oils break down the topmost layer. Experts suggest setting the line with a translucent or matching eyeshadow, or using a primer, to further lock in the color. Without these steps, any gel or pencil liner may experience minor migration on very oily lids.
Allegations & Rumors: Fact vs. Fiction
A handful of reviews reference severe allergic reactions and alarming rumors about carcinogenic ingredients. One user claimed they “developed a severe reaction after months of use” and warned of cancer-causing components. Upon investigation, there are no official FDA warnings or recalls concerning Smashbox Always On Gel Eyeliner. The ingredient list is publicly available—anchored by standard pigments, emollients, and film-forming polymers approved for cosmetic use. If you have a known allergy, performing a patch test or consulting a dermatologist is advisable, but current evidence does not support widespread health hazards or carcinogenic risks in this formula.
Another rumor involves counterfeit “knock-off” eyeliners being sold as Smashbox on third-party platforms. To avoid fakes, buyers should confirm that the listing shows official packaging, batch codes, and seller reputation. Many reviewers noting suspicious packaging purchased from unauthorized resellers, whereas purchasing from the Smashbox website, Sephora, or reputable Amazon “Sold by Smashbox” listings virtually eliminates this risk.
- Best for users seeking all-day waterproof wear and intense pigment payoff.
- Less ideal if you favor twist-up convenience over sharpening maintenance.
Who Should Consider Smashbox Always On Gel Eyeliner?
Smashbox Always On Gel Eyeliner appeals most to those who prioritize longevity and resilience in their eye makeup. If you work in demanding environments—hot kitchens, outdoor events, or emotional days—you’ll value the liner’s capacity to remain crisp and intact. Allergy sufferers and contact lens wearers often report no irritation, making it a strong choice for sensitive eyes. The product also rewards makeup artists who require a dependable base for advanced techniques such as graphic wings or diffused smoky looks.
Conversely, if you dislike pencil sharpeners or need instant twist-up convenience, the Always Sharp version (self-sharpening) may be a better fit. Beginners who struggle with manual sharpeners might find the maintenance routine a barrier, despite the formula’s benefits. For minimalists seeking a one-and-done retractable liner, other gel sticks or liquid liners could be more user-friendly.
In summary, turn to Smashbox Always On Gel Eyeliner if you desire superior wear and waterproof reliability, and are comfortable with a sharpening routine. Otherwise, exploring alternate formats—such as cream pots or retractable sticks—may align better with your application preferences.
- Minor design trade-offs do not overshadow the liner’s exceptional performance.
- Recommended for beauty enthusiasts valuing durability and pigmentation over twist-up ease.
Conclusion: Final Verdict
After reviewing hundreds of user testimonials and dissecting both praise and criticism, the Smashbox Always On Gel Eyeliner stands out as a high-performing gel pencil that truly delivers on its promise of 24-hour, waterproof wear. While the sharpening mechanism and plastic casing introduce occasional frustration—especially for those accustomed to retractable designs—the payoff is a smooth, intensely pigmented line that resists sweat, tears, and humidity. Reports of serious health concerns, such as carcinogenic ingredients, remain unsubstantiated and appear to be isolated rumors rather than industry-backed findings.
For makeup professionals and everyday users alike, this liner offers a versatile tool: blendable for smoky looks, yet capable of razor-sharpened wings. If you’re ready to embrace a short sharpening ritual in exchange for near-bulletproof results, Smashbox Always On Gel Eyeliner is a top recommendation in its category. Should you prefer twist-up convenience, consider the Always Sharp variant or other gel-stick formats—but know that you may trade some of that signature Smashbox staying power in doing so.
Smashbox Always On Gel Eye Liner | Weightless, Long Lasting + Waterproof, 0.04 Ounce
- Glide on Smashbox Always On Gel Eye Liner weightlessly with rich pigment that lasts 24 hours—waterproof, smudge-proof and cruelty-free for bold, flawless eye looks.
- Enjoy buildable application as the gel stays wet seconds to sculpt precise lines or smoky drama. Its cruelty-free, waterproof formula lets you layer and blend for endless, high-impact eye styles.
Comments