Maybelline Shadow Blocks Broadway & Prince St Eyeshadow Trio Review: Pros, Cons & Rumors Debunked

Maybelline New York Shadow Blocks Shadow Blocks Eyeshadow Palette, Stacked Eye Shadow Trio, Broadway & Prince St, 0.08 oz

Bold, blendable color meets NYC inspiration in Shadow Blocks: a travel-ready trio with 2 mattes + 1 shimmer in a pocket-size palette. Soft, buildable formula delivers vibrant looks on the go.
Travel-friendly Shadow Blocks trio blends 2 vibrant mattes with a dazzling shimmer for endless eye looks. Apply with fingertips or brush for precise, mess-free color anytime, anywhere.

Users generally praise blendability and pigmentation.
Some report powdery fallout, breakage, and occasional color shifting.
A single rumor about talc/asbestos remains unverified without official recalls.
No known safety warnings or lawsuits target this product.
Ideal for travel, daily neutral looks, and those comfortable with compact palettes.

Compact trio with two matte shades and one shimmer shade in a stacked design.
Inspired by Brooklyn’s Prince St and Broadway neighborhoods for versatile color range.

Table of contents

Product Overview
Maybelline Shadow Blocks Eyeshadow Palette Review: Honest Findings
Positive Feedback & Highlights
Negative Reviews & Rumor Analysis
Who Should Consider Maybelline Shadow Blocks Eyeshadow Palette?
Conclusion: Final Verdict

Product Overview

The Maybelline Shadow Blocks Eyeshadow Palette – Broadway & Prince St Trio is a travel-friendly beauty essential that fits easily into a purse or makeup bag. Drawing inspiration from the bustling streets of Brooklyn and Manhattan, each pocket-sized cube stacks high-pigment shadows in two matte finishes alongside a shimmering accent. At just 0.08 oz per palette, the formula is designed to be soft, creamy, lightweight, making application smooth whether you use fingertips or a brush.

Maybelline’s marketing highlights both portability and performance, emphasizing bold, saturated color that can be applied with minimal mess. The packaging’s color-coded layers help users quickly identify each shade without guesswork, offering practical convenience for quick touch-ups on the go. Although compact, the trio configuration covers a broad spectrum of uses: from subtle daytime wear to dramatic evening looks.

This product taps into Maybelline’s broader eye collection, including eyeliners, brow pencils, and mascaras, all tailored for a cohesive eye makeup routine. The integrated design complements other brand items such as foundations, concealers, and highlighters to deliver a full-face finish when paired correctly.

Weighing minimal ounces and available at an accessible price point, the Broadway & Prince St Trio promises versatility and portability for both makeup novices and seasoned artists seeking a quick, reliable shadow option.

A balanced mix of positive and negative feedback across verified buyers.
No widespread safety recalls or official hazard warnings have been reported.

Maybelline Shadow Blocks Eyeshadow Palette Review: Honest Findings

The customer response to this eyeshadow palette is a study in contrasts. On one hand, many reviews celebrate the product’s bold color payoff and ease of blending; on the other, detractors highlight issues like fallout and breakage. User ratings average out to around four stars, suggesting general satisfaction with some caveats.

Crucially, despite one user’s claim regarding talc and asbestos contamination, no current regulatory bulletins or consumer safety alerts target this specific palette. A search of official databases and major beauty news sources returns no class-action litigation or recall announcements. This suggests that the rumor remains an isolated anecdote rather than evidence of a systemic safety concern.

From a value perspective, the cost per shadow falls in line with similar drugstore offerings. While some buyers mention that the size feels small relative to single pans in larger palettes, the $3–$4 per shadow breakdown is competitive. Packaging durability appears to be the primary mechanical failure point: multiple reports of shattered pans during shipping imply the cube’s design may require reinforced edges or improved cushioning.

Ultimately, the Honest Findings stage underscores a need to weigh the desirable pigmentation and portability against potential texture and packaging vulnerabilities.

User favorites include blendable, pigmented matte and shimmer combinations.
Travel-friendly format praised for quick, no-mess application.

Positive Feedback & Highlights

A recurring theme among satisfied customers is the rich color payoff. Many note that even a light swipe delivers noticeable hue, allowing for dramatic or subtle looks based on pressure. The interplay of two matte neutrals with one shimmering accent has resonated well, especially for users seeking a minimalist set that can create smoky eyes, everyday contours, or highlight the brow bone.

The blendable formula receives kudos for its smooth, creamy texture. Users report minimal dusting when tapping off excess pigment, reducing cleanup around the eye area. This is especially valued by those who prefer fingertip application — an approach that supports the product’s on-the-go convenience.

Positive reviews also credit the packaging design. The stacked cubes feature an intuitive color-matched shell that lets you identify your preferred shade instantly. Shoppers who purchased multiple palettes appreciated the uniformity in packaging, making it easy to see whether they grabbed the matte brown trio or the bold ruby mix.

Long wear is another highlight, with numerous buyers confirming a lasting finish that endures through typical daytime activities without heavy creasing or fading. For neutral tones like those in Broadway & Prince St, this longevity translates into minimal midday retouches.

Many buyers report crumbly, powdery texture and frequent fallout.
Isolated rumor about talc/asbestos contamination remains unverified.

Negative Reviews & Rumor Analysis

Despite the overall favorable ratings, a substantial minority of users encountered issues that warrant attention. The most common complaint involves a powdery consistency that produces fallout during application, leading to product waste and additional cleanup. Some reviewers mention getting more eyeshadow on surrounding skin or clothing than on their lids.

Packaging durability emerges as another pain point. Multiple customers describe palettes arriving with shattered pans, loose pigment in the box, and unusable shadows. This suggests that the stacked design, while stylish, may lack sufficient internal support for typical shipping stresses. Buyers sensitive to debris or mess in their makeup bags should consider reinforcing the cube with bubble wrap or selecting an alternative palette.

Color accuracy is also questioned by a few. One purchaser reported an unexpected orange cast upon blending, contrasting sharply with the promised neutrals. Such off-hue performance may be due to batch inconsistency or individual skin chemistry, but it represents a legitimate drawback for those expecting faithful shade reproduction.

A single, highly alarming review alleges the presence of talc contaminated with asbestos. This user referenced FDA findings on talc-based product recalls in other cases, expressing deep concern. However, our investigation finds no records of FDA actions or Maybelline recalls for this specific formula. The user’s statement, while serious, stands alone without corroboration from additional buyers or regulatory bodies.

In summary, negative feedback clusters around texture, packaging, and rare color mismatches, while the asbestos rumor lacks substantial verification and appears anecdotal rather than systemic.

Ideal for travelers and makeup minimalists seeking three versatile shades.
Not recommended for those needing heavy-duty pigment or robust pan sizes.

Who Should Consider Maybelline Shadow Blocks Eyeshadow Palette?

This compact palette suits anyone looking for a streamlined makeup routine. If you favor neutral browns and occasional shimmer to complement green, brown, or blue eyes, the Broadway & Prince St combo offers a balanced triad without the bulk of larger kits. Its small footprint makes it easy to slip into a clutch or gym bag.

Travel enthusiasts will appreciate the ability to touch up on the go. The absence of a built-in mirror might seem like a drawback, but it also eliminates extra weight and increases flexibility in pairing with separate mirror compacts or phone cameras. Frequent flyers and city dwellers who need a no-fuss palette will find this design appealing.

Conversely, those seeking bold, highly pigmented jewel tones or extensive shade ranges should look elsewhere. Large-paned palettes with integrated double duty pans or magnetic refill systems may provide better value and durability. Likewise, shoppers with known sensitivities to talc-based formulations should review the detailed ingredient list before purchasing.

Finally, fragrance-sensitive or minimalist-brand devotees may bypass this item, as expanding consumer reviews occasionally note a light cosmetic scent and the inclusion of common drugstore ingredients. Anyone prioritizing all-natural or talc-free cosmetics might consider alternative options.

No significant safety recalls or lawsuits linked to this palette.
Solid value for everyday and on-the-go makeup routines with minor quality caveats.

Conclusion: Final Verdict

The Maybelline Shadow Blocks Eyeshadow Palette – Broadway & Prince St Trio stands out for its blendable matte and shimmer mix, intuitive packaging, and travel-savvy design. Most users report excellent color consistency, enduring wear, and a user-friendly formula that delivers predictable results.

However, potential buyers should remain mindful of isolated texture issues, including powdery fallout and shipping-related breakage. Color fidelity can vary slightly, so if you demand exact online-to-lid matching, further patch tests might be prudent. The rumor about talc contamination, while unsettling, is not substantiated by official recall notices or multiple consumer complaints.

In weighing pros and cons, the Broadway & Prince St palette offers a compelling case for casual users seeking a quick, compact solution. Budget-conscious shoppers get three high-impact shades at a competitive price point, while packaging enthusiasts love the stackable cubes. If ease of use and portability are your top priorities, this palette deserves consideration.

For heavy-duty makeup artists, extended shade diversity seekers, or those with strict ingredient preferences, exploring larger or specialized palettes is recommended. Otherwise, the Maybelline Shadow Blocks Trio remains a reliable, stylish choice for everyday and travel-friendly eye looks.